Report an antisemitic or civil-rights incident

Case Study

Sumrall v. Ali

District of Columbia

Summary

Plaintiff Kimmara Sumrall alleges Defendant Janine Ali grabbed the Israeli flag draped around her neck and choked her with it during a protest.

Holding

"Targeting the Star of David is as racially motivated as the highly offensive racial slur, "n*****""

Purposefully yanking on an Israeli flag tied around a Jewish person's neck to choke them is direct evidence of racial discrimination. The Star of David — emblazoned on the Israeli flag — symbolizes the Jewish race. Battery, particularly involving a racial symbol, is strong evidence of racial discrimination and more severe than racial slurs that alone constitute direct evidence.

Case developments

  1. Israeli-flag choking incident during protests over the war in Gaza

  2. Jul 16, 2025

    Complaint filed

  3. Jul 17, 2025

    Motion for temporary restraining order

  4. Aug 4, 2025

    Court granted the motion

    Ali's battery against Sumrall constitutes direct evidence of racial discrimination.

Get involved

Join JCAC to stay updated on our legal advocacy work and support our mission.

Become a free member